Pip: Welcome to The Hell's Kitchen Writer, where the holidays come with a Rod Serling chaser and a side of political prophecy from 1964.

Mara: S.W. Laro is writing about a lost television special, what it said about race and war, and why it still lands sixty years later. Let's start with the special itself and the personal story behind finding it.

A little substack for ya on my Word Press site!

Pip: The setup here is deceptively personal — a grieving son scrolling YouTube on Christmas afternoon, and then something unexpected surfaces, almost like it was placed there.

Mara: The post describes exactly that moment: "his Spirit plugged in on Christmas afternoon at around 3:45pm when on YouTube as I scrolled through movies and old holiday specials including Andy William Christmas Special. Suddenly, there was a Rod Serling special titled, 'Carol for Another Christmas' (1964)."

Pip: So a father who loved Rod Serling passes away, and on the first Christmas without him, his son finds a Serling special he'd apparently never seen. That's not a coincidence the post is willing to dismiss.

Mara: And the special itself turns out to be genuinely remarkable. The cast runs from Peter Sellers to Robert Shaw to Eva Marie Saint, directed by Joseph L. Mankiewicz with a Henry Mancini score — serious talent assembled for something that may never have actually aired.

Pip: May never have aired — which, given what's in it, starts to make a certain amount of sense.

Mara: The post describes a scene that's hard to look away from: a well-dressed white child in a cowboy outfit shooting a Black man with what appears to be a toy gun, in front of his mother, who doesn't react at all. Serling wrote that scene in 1964, four years before the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.

Pip: Serling's whole method was political metaphor wrapped in genre — science fiction, surrealism, the uncanny — and this special takes that approach and turns it directly on race hatred and the machinery of war.

Mara: The post draws a straight line from the special's third act — Peter Sellers playing what gets called a "crazed dear leader" commanding a post-apocalyptic following — to the present political moment. The Dickens structure is the vehicle; the target is contemporary.

Pip: A Christmas Carol as a delivery system for anti-fascist argument. Serling understood that the sugarcoating is what gets the medicine past the door.

Mara: The post also honors the casting — Lynn Stalmaster and James Lister are named — and notes that the Twilight Zone's eye for talent launched careers for Robert Redford, Robert Duvall, Charles Bronson, and others. The craftsmanship throughout was serious, even if the broadcast history remains murky.

Mara: What the post keeps returning to is that the distance between 1964 and now is smaller than it should be — on race, on war, on who gets to look away.


Pip: A grieving son, a lost Serling broadcast, and sixty years of American political theater that apparently needed no updates.

Mara: The questions Serling was asking in 1964 are still the ones on the table. That's the thread worth pulling next time.

Leave a Reply